This past weekend I needed a film I could jump in and out of several times while eating lunch or dinner and not really care about what happens next, so I watched
Daredevil. Here's why it utterly fails as a film:
During the day, Daredevil's alter ego works as a lawyer, so as opposed to other superheros who simply capture the bad guys and tie them up in webbing or leave them dangling from street lamps for the cops to pickup, he's already tried the court system and must now bring his own form of justicehe kills them! As much as the audience sees the twisted need for this, they also know how inherently wrong it is. He's a hero we must struggle to root for, which makes for very uncomfortable viewing.
At times his blindness is used to reveal his humanity, such as the way he folds a ten dollar bill differently from a five so he can distinguish between them as he goes to pay for something. And every time he uses his radar to do something a normal blind person couldn't, like telling someone to "watch your step" or stopping Stan Lee, with his nose buried in a newspaper, from walking in front of a truck, we get a small smile on our face.
There are other character quirks, however, that they never explain. He sleeps in a water-filled coffin; that's cool, but why? A sound transition as he laid down to muffle the world so he could sleep would have been both informative and really stylish.
As if these inconsistencies weren't enough, when Daredevil's normal alter ego meets the love of his life, she rejects him and walks out of the cafe they're in. All right, conflict's not such a bad thingbut then he follows her down the street like a creepy stalker! No one wants a guy like that. So what do these star-crossed lovers do? Fight of course (which is unfortunately the best scene in the film). Moments like these are just absurd and destroy any credibility the story might have had.
On top of that, the film comes off as a strange mix of bubbly comicbook and gothic horror elements that fail to blend. The secondary villain, Bullseye (played by Colin Farrell), with a grin like Jack Nicholson in
The Shining and an actual bullseye tattooed on his forehead, is perhaps the campiest character to ever grace the screen. Yet despite his eerily clownish nature, he manages to kill Daredevil's love interest.
Although these extremely dark moments aren't necessarily bad in and of themselves, they're completely unexpected for a story with characters in ruby rubber suits. In the end, the filmmakers go too far in breaking the expectations of the audience to the point they are no longer trusted.